IMMORTAL SONG 2 EP 5

[jaejunggim.livejournal.com]

Min Hye Kyung

Lee Hong Ki

G.O

Round 1 Result

Junsu

Round 2 Result

Changmin

Round 3 Result

Hyorin

Round 4 Result

Ji Eun

Final Result

This week their mission was to remake songs from Min Hae Kyung.

Min Hae Kyung - You Are A Rose
HONGKI - You're Laughing Like A Doll But...
G.O - You're Love Is Enough
ROUND 1 RESULT - G.O VS HONGKI
JUNSU - I Wanna See Your Face
ROUND 2 RESULT - JUNSU VS G.O
CHANGMIN - You're Laughing Like A Doll But
ROUND 3 RESULT - CHANGMIN VS G.O
HYORIN - Mini Skirt
ROUND 4 RESULT - HYORIN VS G.O
SONG JI EUN - Whose Life Is It Anyway
FINAL RESULT~~~


SOURCE: BberiBubbles5 ; koreanlover1fan2

Comments

[cher-ex3.livejournal.com]

Already owned from the practice

[love-keiko.livejournal.com]

oh wow! that was all kinds of flawless!!!

FT Island ♥

[oystersauce87.livejournal.com]

Love their performance. I think it's amazing that Hongki is not only showing his vocals but help the other members showcasing their talent by bringing them on the show as well.

Re: FT Island ♥

[twinkystar16.livejournal.com]

yup..i like how he included the rest of ft island in his perf...and it's also LIVE!!

[blastoise.livejournal.com]

so proud of g.o bb for making it so far, i was shaking and crying the whole episode

[shocko-o.livejournal.com]

kim heechul on immortal song? with hongki?

[twinkystar16.livejournal.com]

next episode..episode 6

[linzer-jello.livejournal.com]

When Kyuhyun gets here, there won't need to be a competition.

[lilykt7.livejournal.com]

wait...wut?

[suzieeq-luv.livejournal.com]

Hyorin's body is ridiculous :Q___

And I loved Hongki's performance this week.

[suzieeq-luv.livejournal.com]

And CHANGMIN I <3 U!!!!

Someone needs to give it up for the 4 awesome chicks doing the back vocals O.o

[lilykt7.livejournal.com]

i don't know who Min Hye Kyung is but she looks like such a fierce bitch omg

[clayray3290.livejournal.com]

Rant time. I wasn’t wowed by any of the performances. They were all solid, but no performance I feel the compulsion to rewatch.

Hongki - A fun performance, but it didn’t really demonstrate anything vocally. I appreciate how Hongki wanted to show off the charms of all of FT Island, but I think that might also be his downfall. The people who win in this show have to approach this with a bit of selfishness - they have to put aside thoughts of their group and only think about themselves. It’s a competition and if they want to win, they have to treat it as such. Another concern I have is that he’s going to end up being one note - he has to venture into different styles. If Hongki decides he cares about winning (which he has tweeted saying he doesn’t) then he’s going to need to change, but if he just cares about having fun and making music, then he’s doing just fine.

G.O. - G.O.’s performance was nice. To be honest, I didn’t actually pay attention the whole time. I thought G.O. came off as a bit nervous - his voice was thinner than it usually was, I thought. The dancing was cute, and I liked how he had a sense of humor about his dancing. I thought the way they edited the song was very suitable to the charming kind of persona that he gave off on stage. G.O. came off of as classy and sophisticated, which he doesn’t always get to show with MBLAQ.

Junsu - Oh Junsu. I didn’t think it was as bad as Junsu seemed to feel it was. So yeah, he kinda failed at taking off his jacket or whatever and thus missed a few lines, but he keeped on with his performance and it was fine. I am still of the opinion that Junsu does too much with the vocal theatrics and his voice doesn’t always support them, but the intro bit was good, despite those theatrics. I liked how he really tried to interact with the audience.

Changmin - Changmin is always so fun to watch. I feel like so far on this show, attempts at taking the songs in a more acoustic and breezy direction have not gone over well with the audience. The audience likes those over-the-top in-your-face kind of flamboyant performances, while this kind of style is much more understated. But I thought Changmin’s performance was really enjoyable. I loved the note at the end - it was such a surprise but thus memorable and cute and just made me smile.

Hyorin - Hyorin has the most to gain from this show, as Sistar is the least well-known of the groups represented on this show. But here’s the thing - Hyorin’s not on this show to get Sistar’s name out there. She’s on this show to win for herself. I’m not saying it's a bad thing - Hyorin is a great entertainer and she’s been very clever about calculating the best moves. But because of her competitiveness and because her aim is focused on winning, Hyorin always uses the same tricks that are showy and easily gets the audience’s attention. But being loud and belting is not all that it takes to be a good singer. There’s very little subtlety to Hyorin’s singing. Hyorin really hasn’t branched out very far and attempted things that she may not be very good at so that she can learn from it. And also, I wish Hyorin could do something…classier.

Jieun - Sampling ‘Madonna’ was risky, putting in a song from someone else when your audience is full of fans of the original artist. Using just the chorus meant the audience had to fill in the connections that the idea is to tell your parents that you can take care of your own life so that you can be the ‘Madonna’ that you can be. I thought this was musically a brilliant idea, but not thinking about the audience. This song, like her previous selections, didn’t have enough momentum, which means Jieun didn’t have the opportunity to show off her voice. Jieun was right in her talking bit - She's never done something with the willingness to step on others to get to the top. But this show is a competition and in order to succeed, she does have to make somebody else feel bad. But she didn’t approach this show with the need to win, so she didn't tailor her performances so that she could.

To be honest, I’m more excited about some of the duet partners next week than the normal cast…Especially J-Lim and Lee Younghyun.

[ryukokoro-oppa.livejournal.com]

This pretty much. I felt this was the most lacking episode so far. I liked G.O.'s performance and I felt bad for Junsu. Changmin is so consistent with great performances, I don't think he's done a mediocre one so far. <3

HongKi...I actually really didn't like this performance at all. I didn't like the arrangement of the song and I feel as if he's trying to use his spot on the show to showcase everyone else except himself..i.e. bringing in the rest of the group..and he chose HeeChul as a partner next week.

I just really can't get into any of Jieun's performances..I really try to get into them..but I just can't. Listening to the audio is actually better than watching the video but neither are spectacular.

Hyorin..I agree with you completely about Hyorin actually. Last week's performance was actually my favorite by her when she sat down and sang and didn't belt as much.

Can't wait for next week with those partners. n__n

[jumpsama.livejournal.com]

I'm afraid this is becoming Hyorin's show already. girl's getting the reputation that's hard to beat. in my case, I enjoyed G.O's song more. I liked the melody, the arrangement, the song's stucked in my mind unlike Hyorin's. but that's just me.

and lol Hongki being butthurt for the 2 vote difference between him and G.O (if my interpretation is correct). they should make it an odd number to avoid ties.

just one thing I hate, when they start with a slow arrangement then suddenly a band comes, I don't like it. it's like I'm about to fall asleep, why do they need to wake me up? maybe that's the reason why I enjoyed G.O's consistency.

[fallingstarryuu.livejournal.com]

hm... I felt the this ep and the previous one were disappointing in terms of performance. I liked some but I wasn't completely wowed to repeat performances these two eps.

I found it really cool Jieun sampled Madonna into her performance, which was a nice touch but she's not really showing off her vocals imo =(

I'm hoping for more performances like Hyorin's That Person Then, Jieun's Reminiscence III and Yesung's The More I Love.

[clayray3290.livejournal.com]

This! Those three performances were three of my faves from this show. :)

[lydzi.livejournal.com]

JiEun you need to cover a Tori Amos song. Really. With your voice it would be perfect. It would be powerful.



Anyway, I love the risky part (sampling Madonna was effin cool srs2say) and how much he meant to her.

[sandra-hall.livejournal.com]

wow hyorin how bucks fizz

[the-erotomanic.livejournal.com]

can't wait for luna to appear in this show. i think she's as talented as hyorin and has the same kind of showmanship.

i'm surprised that changmin hasn't won anything, yet. he's so good. maybe too good that the standards for him are much higher?

[liliumlied.livejournal.com]

omg me too Luna has also a great voice and her dancing skills are as good as hyorin's or maybe better should I say ? But she lacks in sexyness tho

[aniloratka.livejournal.com]

Hyorin is the best. And Junsu's perf was cool too :)

[aya-sama3000.livejournal.com]

ICU staring Junsu
Hyorin's miniskirt brings all the boys to her yard.

I really liked Changmin's performance the most, then Hyorin, and Junsu, and GO :3

i cant wait till Luna's on the show...i wonder if shes gonna cry before she gets to sing, afterwards, or after the light goes off in the round battles...my guess is all 3...

[vitaminbaby.livejournal.com]

hahahahaa @ your last comment!

[iznanassi.livejournal.com]

The way G.O was looking at Hyorin makes me ship them lol.

[clayray3290.livejournal.com]

I was debating whether to ship G.O./Hyorin or Junsu/Hyorin - I know it wasn't meant that way, but I thought it was hilarious how Junsu commented, "Wow, she's really good at taking off her clothes."

[691979082.livejournal.com]

Congrats to Hyorin. I don't like her, but I gotta give the girl credit for snatching all my faves wigs rn. Work it, gurl.

And Changmin, omg all kinds of adorable in those backstage clips. Someone was in a good mood. LOL. Hoongki, Junsu and G.O were lots of fun (even though I kept singing "Hey Jude" over the end of G.O's song... >_>;;;;). I feel like Jieun didn't try hard enough this week, when she wasn't singing Madonna she felt to me like she was holding back. IDK, she needs to come harder. I love her but it always seems like she holds back just that little bit from putting 100% of her emotions into it.

[weerainbow.livejournal.com]

I really have to say that Changmin looks like he's having an absolute blast on this show!!! ^^

[yeongwonnie.livejournal.com]

when is Changmin going to finally win in this show?
he was the most consistent with great performances since the 1st episode

Hyorin I love you but don't you think it's enough with showing off like that? we want classier, let's say, performances & I'm sure you can do it
(btw congrats on making the boys have a boner, especially Junsu, he was practically drooling lool!)

as for the rest of the participants, they're good but I'm sorry to say that since they joined in I found the show rather boring. I understand it's not their fault, the episodes "themes" weren't good like, say, the BooHwal epiosde whish was the best as far. I might be biased but I want my Yesung back in The More I love You attitude -_-

let's hope the next episode with the duets will be better
the preview is quite interesting (though I'm not sure about Heechul participation as much as I love the man :/ )

[voleur.livejournal.com]

lol i love this comment...and dude i agree about changmin. i really wanna see him win already, though i admit hyorin is amazing and all. but i think i have the most consistent fun watching changmin perform, ngl.

[earenya-beryl.livejournal.com]

I love Hyorin, one of the reasons I started watching this show (apart from Jjong) but her dance breaks are becoming very predictable now.

[rikayla.livejournal.com]

Hmmmm, I want CSJH Dana or Sunday on this show if they're gonna be promoting soon heh.

[modestgoddess79.livejournal.com]

Junsu you better get your woman!

[mappingemotion.livejournal.com]

They're making it so easy for me to ship them, so easy.

[modestgoddess79.livejournal.com]

she gonna give that boy a heart attack

[hitsujiga.livejournal.com]

if hyorin did just a bit less show i could agree with her winning. and she always chooses to do something impressive or shows off her body or sings something equally suggestive, i get the impression.

if it wasn't for G.O's awkward/badly timed moves and his almost emotionless face he would have slayed err'one this time. because vocally he was the most stable and most impressive for me. i appreciated the assgrab though. 8D slay.O will slay dem all next time! 8DDD
bb, if your face would hold as much emotion as your voice does you would be so perfect! ;O;<3

[voleur.livejournal.com]

hongki: i really enjoyed this perf...his vocals were pretty strong, but the music was too damn loud and there wasn't much of a climax. i know it's a rock rendition, but come ON now the people need to hear more of that voice to judge him more accordingly.

G.O. - i'm gunna be honest here and say i was kinda bored. don't get me wrong - i've been a fan of g.o. ever since his debut with mblaq and he was instantly my fave after i heard him sing for his old group teykeys. but that's exactly why i was kinda bored with his performance: i've seen him do much better!! but i'm still happy he made it so far! he kept it classy and smooth. (;

junsu - i thought he did well, but it wasn't memorable for me. literally. i can't seem to write much about it right now because i don't remember much from it...lol.

changmin - this man knows how to perform. he knows how to light up the whole damn room and just charm the audience like it's a piece of cake. seriously, he's SO GOOD. his voice is like BUTTA. i preferred his performance over g.o.'s, although i admit changmin's song might have been a little too laid back. but that last note was amazin.

hyorin - not my favorite performance from her...though her vocals are still freakin amazing. but hyorin, girl, you gotta start changing things up!! now you're looking a little too showy, a little too sexy, a little too loud. i think it's GREAT that she's getting the attention she deserves, esp since sistar is still down there in terms of popularity, but now hyorin needs to start toning it down and bringing out a classier, more sophisticated side. but at the same time...she looks like she's having a blast every time i see her perform, so part of me is thinking that maybe "toning" it down might be bad afterall. who knows. either way, that girl is a freakin powerhouse and is def one to look out for.

jieun - i was really rootin for her...i felt bad for this girl. but man, this performance was a mess. she tried SO hard too...you could tell. and honestly i think that also messed her up: i think you could see her desperation in this, and so it came out sloppy and just...): shame, really.