151008 MNET M! COUNTDOWN E446

[kevinmchale.livejournal.com]

Winners Announcement

	GOT7 'If You Do'	IKON 'Rhythm Ta'
Digital Sales (음원 판매 점수)	1924	3267
Physical Album Sales (음반 판매 점수)	1500	0
Viewer Votes (선호도 점수)	632	990
Social Media (소셜미디어 점수)	1500	931
Mnet Broadcast Points (엠넷 방송 점수)	760	880
Final Total	6864	7068

FULL SHOW

Part ONE

Part TWO

COMEBACK STAGES

[ 2BIC — 지금처럼 사랑할게 I Will Love You Like Now ]

DEBUT STAGES

REGULAR STAGES

TEASERS

OTHER CUTS

[ MCD Chart: 10-3 ]

sources: Mnet, Skpb K-Music Live

Comments

[chastainy.livejournal.com]

i can't believe they keep winning for this flat ass song, god7s comeback is lightyears better!

[ah-mui.livejournal.com]

Did they win with Rhythm Ta before? Thought it was My Type.

But yeah, as someone who generally likes every song YG puts out I love If You Do loads more than any song on iKon's album

[ah-mui.livejournal.com]

Got7 lost? Noooo :( If only their broadcast points were higher

[paravion23.livejournal.com]

i dont even get how ikon HAD BROADCAST POINTS??

[patentpending.livejournal.com]

Poor Got7, I was hoping they had a chance at Mnet with the stuff going on between them and YG but alas. At least they got a show champion win, even though it is the least relevant of all the shows.

[cosmicfish.livejournal.com]

It was on The Show not Show Champ, even less relevant (and I dont mean this in a catty way lmao)

[fabulousdoll.livejournal.com]

MTE about GOT7. I'm pretty sure they're already happy with the good results they're getting. I'm not too worried about them.

[nefertitii.livejournal.com]

so close...

so...

so..

close

[gathyou.livejournal.com]

The Playback song was so light and cute, when was this released??
GOT7's song is still so great. Same as Lovelyz. I enjoy seeing them hitting their moves hard (in a different way ofc)
I am always amazed at the early beginning of Red Velvet's choreo, where Irene is so still, almost blank, and then *bam* action! and she's just everything. I love them.

As I said already, Oh My Girl's stage was gorgeous and the girls are totally slaying. Also, Taeyeon is making me so emotional with her happiness.

[seulgibear.livejournal.com]

damn got7 so close :( they look so good in those all black outfits, i'm feeling things
TAEYEON LOOKS AMAZING and her stage is gorgeous. i am the heart eyes emoji
still need to check out oh my girls comeback, if i don't forget

[fabulousdoll.livejournal.com]

I'm obsessed with Closer. Oh My Girl's stage gave me chills.
Lovelyz <3 Their choreography is so lovelyz

[sra-interesante.livejournal.com]

cute playback girls , no wonder is growing on me

no idea they had a tag already

yay!!

[inkbracket.livejournal.com]

Hopefully, Got7 will win on another show this week. They deserve to win.
Oh My Girl's song is everything and the live performance is perfection.
I like Ikon's album,but honestly these music shows need a policy of no promotion, you can't be nominated. I don't understand why YG release half of their debut album, send them to one music show, and then send them off overseas.

[rivains.livejournal.com]

mte they really do. Exo and BigBang won on music shows they never bothered to perform at, and unless the music show has a special non-attendance policy acts who have no plans to set foot onto that show's stage for however long their promo cycle is, they shouldn't be allowed to win at all. it defeats the point of a music show.

[kwikimart.livejournal.com]

good for iKON, I hope the next half of the album gives us more Chanwoo and songs like Rhythm Ta. Lmaoo Bobby keeps beating all my faves, first Iron now GOD7 and yet I still like him lol.
GOD7 are doing so well this comeback, I'm proud of them, they've been getting so much more notice, JYP needs to get them all out there promoting in different venues tho not just Jackson (as much as I love him!). I hope they get another trophy but I'm really happy with their progress so far.
I need to check out this Taeyeon lady's stage, she looks gorgeous

[suhrose.livejournal.com]

it shouldve gone to god7 JUST for being born since thats much better than anything ik*n will contribute to the world with their garbage noise music and hideousness

[lily-of-west.livejournal.com]

Honey if there's any garbage noise and hideousness here it's coming from you.

[miwa201.livejournal.com]

what a shame, i really wanted got7 to win. do they have a chance to win on music bank? i know they prob want a public broadcast win.
congrats to ikon tho, are they not going to promote on mcountdown at all now?
ailee is so amazing, she's really something else in terms of stage presence.
man, taeyeon's face looks so weird now. her eyes are unnaturally big. i hope it's just circle lenses

[darkensunrise.livejournal.com]

whatever. WHATEVER

at least god7 is full of visuals and makes good music WHATEVER

no but really how does ik*n manage to get broadcast points despite not even promoting on the fucking show. fuck this.

[lily-of-west.livejournal.com]

Easy just like other people before them got broadcast points when they didn't attend.

And you can keep your "visuals" because thank god not everyone has the same taste.

[pinklunacy.livejournal.com]

Taeyeon's and Oh my Girl's stages were amazingly beautiful. And both songs are so nice to listen to <3

These make up for GOT7 not winning on any major show so far despite them promoting their best song since they debuted.

[hipployta.livejournal.com]

Congrats iKON!!! Proud of your sucess and the support in Korea. Good job GOT7! They are getting so much attention too.

So...because I get the sense people don't know or are confused by the broadcast points: They are for appearance on a channel but also for how often the song is played on the channel as a MV or background music. Also if they have a radio station associated with the channel those plays count too.

That is why iKON can not perform but still have broadcast points.

A no-attendence no-win policy would further undermine the credibility of these shows because the public already questions why a lot of songs with extremely poor digitals win because of fandom bulk buying albums and voting.



1.[+2771, -525] ikon, congratulation on your number 1. got7, good job too
2.[2515, -466] Uwa, that was a close one. ikon, congrats on your no 1. got7 too, let's rise more in the future
3.[+2148, -606] ikon, congrats on your number 1. i really like ikon's song this time. i wish you daebak in the future.
4. [+1989, -510] congrats on your number 1. i wanted to see ikon's stage too. it's too bad ㅠㅠ
5. [+1871,-489] ikon, congrats on your number 1.
6. [+499, -84] i wasnt expecting this. congrats on your number 1. those got7 people, good job too
7. [+512, -98] got7, good job too. ikon-ah, congrats for the first place

cr: OH (http://onehallyu.com/topic/230474-ikonbuzz-top-comments-on-ikon-1-win-on-mcountdown/)

Taeyeon sold 30,000 albums in 2 days and is #1 on Melon...all the shows belong to her next week

[djeedjes.livejournal.com]

I'm just happy to see GOT7 performing...not only have to hear their song on my phone.
It's okay boys, you'll reap what you sow one day! It'll get better from now, and I'm happy they gained more fans~

ah, and they all look so damn good in all black!

[gray-fairy.livejournal.com]

I feel so bad for GOT7. This song is probably their best title track ever but even so they keep failing to appeal the public :/. But digital points aside, they could have won this time if it wasn't for the broadcast points. How do iKON have broadcast points if they haven't promoted or have appeared in any MNet show as far I know?

Is Kyuhyun really coming back next week? I haven't seen any teasers or anything by now ._.

wow @ some of the comments here tho. People REALLY despise iKON.

[lily-of-west.livejournal.com]

Answer is 2 comments above you.

[atopworld.livejournal.com]

Damn it. SO CLOSE.

[uledy.livejournal.com]

ooooh, i really like playback's song! i think they're so pretty and unique looking, i can't really explain it. gonna go watch all their stuff now...seventeen- excellent as ever. homme- so glad they're back!

idc about got7 or ikon, but these shows are never about which song is the better or whatever, even when our faves win.

[rivains.livejournal.com]

i wouldn't be so pressed (because LETS BE REAL, got7's digitals are pretty bad, although their physicals are great, but the digital points matter) if mnet hadn't let ikon be in the running for a win the other week against RV because they didn't perform. they didn't perform this week, and somehow the ban was lifted. this is partially down to mnet being a bag of inconsistent shit, but i'd be annoyed as well if another group who also could do with a win were up against a group who didn't even perform at the show.

[hearttaek.livejournal.com]

I guess mnet and yg have made up.
Because mnet can give (and have given) groups 0 broadcast points for pissing them off. Purposely not letting the group appear on mca and not playing the music at all in the channel from bgm, to music video plays.

Vixx won with zero broadcast points and weren't invited on mca for a whole era. I think mca pulled that stunt with teentop too (or was it infinite) for having comebacks in showchamp.

[rivains.livejournal.com]

wasn't ikon not allowed to win on mcd last week because they didn't perform... hm

[szhuns.livejournal.com]

lmao noah fence but there are a few users on omona who consistently do the most and i'm like, genuinely worried for their well-being. how do you even survive irl?? like i know everyone loves their faves but this is kpop, why are you taking it so seriously??

anyways, i've never watched every performance from a group's comeback until seventeen's mansae. they're just so likable and entertaining! really excited to see them grow as artists and as individuals.

got7 is great as always, definitely proud of them and how much they've accomplished.

[hitthoselightz.livejournal.com]

mte to the first part

[wishesgranted.livejournal.com]

I feel for GOT7 because their song and performances are really good, but I'm still happy for IKON. I like their music.

[yw7.livejournal.com]

whoever that is in your icon looks gorgeous!!

[awsteven.livejournal.com]

oh my girl's performance was perfection. both the choreo and the song are gorgeous. couldn't keep my eyes off of yooa.

got7 was flawless. wish they won but at least they're getting a lot of positive attention and support from other fandoms. love the oomph the instrumental of the song has. adds to the performance.

taeyeon <333 she looked so happy and pretty and sung beautifully. the stage was breathtaking and i felt so happy when the flower petals starting falling lol

seventeen and red velvet were great like always

lmao @ the drama in this post. comment section of music show posts have been entertaining recently