who got eliminated from omona's fave female idol variety show Secret Weapon??

[rightclick5ave.livejournal.com]

Secret Weapon Ep4 & 5 highlights

10 girl group members compete in weekly missions based on a celeb role model, judged by a panel of 10 'holic' fans.
The winner of each episode gets to be filmed by professional fancammers.
The overall winner of the show will appear on Weekly Idol with her group.
@mbcgirl2015 | @ScrtWeaponUpdt | streaming link (Fri 6pm KST)

Clockwise from top left:
Sihyun (Spica)
Dahye (BESTie)
Solbin (Laboum)
Yerin (GFriend)
Minhee (Stellar)
Daye (Berry Good)
Alice (Hello Venus)
Jei (Fiestar)
Jisoo (TAHITI)
Daeun (2Eyes)

Episode 4 & 5's role model: CL

Unique fashion sense, multingualism, healthy body, rapping

I'm too lazy to save and reupload fantakens from the filming: smilewa 1 & 2 + The Studio


Episode 4

ROUND 1: High fashion poses

they had a 'high fashion' photoshoot, which meant that they took photos in weird positions and modelling school students voted for their fave.

Round 1 ranking:

1. Solbin (20 votes)


2. Jisoo (16)


3. Alice (14)


4. Minhee (12)


5. Jei (11)


6. Daye (9)


7. Yerin (6)


8. Dahye (5)


9. Sihyun (4)


10. Daeun (3)



ROUND 2: Debate

this role model trait was about CL's multilingualism and braininess, so they looked at the girls' academic records and other talents, and they had 3min 1v1 debates and solo speeches. (I won't translate their debates, but if anyone wants to know the gist of any argument just leave a comment!)

3-MINUTE DEBATE

10 billion won to go solo
proposition: Jei
opposition: Yerin
WINNER: Jei (10 votes to 1)

if my contract is up, I will...
sign with a small but close-knit agency: Daeun
sign with a huge company: Solbin
WINNER: Daeun (8 votes to 2)

I would prefer to...
become a top star in one year and then retire: Alice
play second fiddle but have a 10-year career: Jisoo
WINNER: Alice (8 votes to 2)

Secret Weapon elimination format
proposition: Daye
opposition: Sihyun
WINNER: Sihyun (9 votes to 1)

relationships
secret relationship: Dahye
public relationship: Minhee
WINNER: Dahye (9 votes to 1)


1-MINUTE SPEECH (topic: are idol groups 'singers' or 'performers'?)

all of them chose 'singers'
Jei: 7 votes
Dahye: 7 votes
Sihyun: edited out
Daeun: edited out
Alice: 9 votes (WINNER)

Round 2 ranking:
1. Alice
2. Dahye, Jei
4. Daeun
5. Sihyun
6. Jisoo, Solbin
8. Minhee, Daye
10. Yerin

note: there was no 'winner' for ep4 since it was a two-parter


Episode 5

ROUND 3: Body management tips

most of this segment was edited out for time, but it's similar to ep1 where the girls all filmed 3-minute videos, this time about how they stay healthy and fit (they're all basically cooking and working out lol). if the judges didn't like the videos or found them boring, they'd hit their red buttons and the video would be stopped. the longer their video gets to play, the higher their ranking.

Round 3 ranking:

1. Jisoo

2. Alice

3. Sihyun

4: Solbin

5: Dahye

6. Daye

7. Minhee

8. Daeun

9. Jei

10: Yerin

ROUND 4: Rap battle

this round was pretty entertaining tbh.. I was pleasantly surprised by Minhee and Jisoo's rapping tones, and Alice's Nutella/Interstellar diss was SO bad and hilarious lol. (I won't be embedding the clips because they're unsubbed, but you can watch them on MBC Every1's channel here)

1v1 BATTLES

battle of the rappers

Dahye (15) vs Sihyun (10)

battle of the maknaes

Solbin (26) vs Yerin (6)

battle of the 'body-dols'

Minhee (28) vs Alice (18)

battle of the 'gag-dols'

Daye (30) vs Daeun (25)

battle of the rivals

Jisoo (29) vs Jei (24)

the winners then did solo raps about themselves.

Round 4 rankings:
1. Solbin (28)
2. Jisoo (26)
3. Daye (22)
4. Dahye (21)

5. Minhee (11)

EP4/5 FINAL RANKING
1. Jisoo!
2. Solbin
3. Alice
4. Dahye
5. Jei, Daye
7. Minhee
8. Sihyun
9. Daeun
10. Yerin

CUMULATIVE RANKINGS + ELIMINATIONS

the original intention was to eliminate the bottom 5 based on their cumulative rankings from eps 1-5, but since there was a tie for 5th place, only 4 were to be eliminated and replaced by another member from their respective groups.


CUMULATIVE RANKINGS (EPS 1-5)
1. Dahye
2. Daeun
3. Jisoo, Alice
5. Sihyun, Solbin

BOTTOM FOUR: Yerin, Minhee, Daye, Jei

BUT PLOT TWIST! after filming ended, the bottom four's managers met individually with the show's PD and discussed possible member replacements. turns out the managers have the power to decide whether they want to switch out the girls with another member or keep them on the show, so...

FINAL DECISIONS: Jei and Daye will be replaced by other members from their respective groups, while Minhee and Yerin will remain on the show.

I'm glad that these two eps were more entertaining and didn't focus on their bodies for once, but what kind of pointless elimination concept... glad for Yerin and Minhee, but I'll miss Daye's explosive reactions and Jei's chipmunk face and faux-rivalry with Jisoo :( but oh well... both Berry Good and Fiestar get to have more member exposure, so that's the bright side I guess? not that this shitty show is helping any of the cast members anyway

ENGSUB EP1: kshowonline
raw eps: 4a 4b | 5a 5b
chisub eps: 4a 4b | 5

cuts: MBC Every1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
fancams: Spinel | smile -wA-
fantakens: smilewa 1 & 2 | The Studio

Comments

[adenar.livejournal.com]

JEI WAS TOO GOOD FOR THIS SHOW
she's also not much of a secret weapon since she's one of the more popular members imo? maybe yezi or cao lu will get some time to shine (on this questionable programme but whatever)

[rightclick5ave.livejournal.com]

I hope Jei has been getting more rest and not falling sick anymore.. I would love to see Cao Lu but if Jei couldn't get screentime I think Lulu would fare even worse lol. Yezi probably suits this concept more!

[fabulousdoll.livejournal.com]

I never thought they will end up subbing it. And now I don't know if I want to watch it, maybe I will watch the part when Sihyun had to answer a couple of questions.

[rightclick5ave.livejournal.com]

I saw someone on twitter who was subbing it but idk if they uploaded it to kshowonline or it's a separate thing..

anyway if you just want to watch Sihyun's cuts (including the one you mentioned)... Mercury Subs to your rescue! all the links here: http://twitter.com/MercurySubs

[magicpineapple.livejournal.com]

aka some of the most & generous ppl ever bless them 🙏

[rightclick5ave.livejournal.com]

thank you, I'll make sure to pass on the kind words to my friends :P we don't have proper subbers but we do what we can!

[magicpineapple.livejournal.com]

Thanks for the updates, OP! I have much to catch up on, it seems, lol 😁

[iznanassi.livejournal.com]

Jei shouldn't even have been on this show

[forsureyoudo.livejournal.com]

lol why its not like shes soo popular~

[leopolitan.livejournal.com]

the part where they meet privately with the PD to decide who stays and leaves sounds kind of skeevy lmao

anyway i hope cao lu replaces jei shes my fav fiestar

[rightclick5ave.livejournal.com]

hahaha thankfully it was all on camera and the managers just gave their opinions/suggestions to the PD

[lydz19.livejournal.com]

Didn't know about that show before the CL role model episode lol