SHINee - ELLE GIRL December Vol. "Who Is The Strongest Idol in 2009 The Year of Idol Battle?"

[musikq.livejournal.com]

Note from Translator: She translated it in a rush so the names of the critics might not be precisely exact.
It is only SHINee- relevant. EDIT: the chinese source only had the SHINee bits and not the others. Sorry about that prev misinform

ELLE GIRL December Vol. "Who Is The Strongest Idol in 2009 The Year of Idol Battle?"

1. 2009 Best Idol Group
2. Member with the best vocals.
3. Most stylish member.
4. Member with the best body.
5. Member who looks the most attractive/charismatic
6. Member who is slightly underrated.
7. Member whose solo debut will be most anticipated.
8. Member whose activities in other arenas will be anticipated.
9. My dream group.
10. The group that is most likely to last very long.


Cha Hyunjin (Mass Communication and Culture Critic)

2. SHINee Jonghyun- ★Member with the best vocals★
Jonghyun who used to be a member of a punk rock band before entering SM, possesses a unique and beautiful voice and smooth usage of different techniques, making it irresistable to be not biased to Jonghyun's vocal.

3. SHINee Taemin- ★Most stylish member★
If in the idol world, 2PM is the epitome of the 'male body', then SHINee is the group that shows the 'shedding of traces of growing up'. In this way. Taemin as a teenager, presents his charms soundlessly to everyone. His own style can also be said to be a innate expression of excellence.

5. SHINee Minho- ★Member who looks the most attractive/charismatic★
The criteria for a pretty boy may be always changing, but 'looks' are still affirmed with no relation to time or era. That's the case for Jang Dong Gun, Jung Hyun Sung and Jo In Sung. There will be no objections to including Minho amongst them.

10. Big Bang & SHINee- ★The group that is most likely to last very long★
As of now, SHINee appears to have the most room for development/growing up. Am also anticipating Big Bang to fully conquer the Asian market, so I see the possibilities of these two groups being able to last long in the industry.


Kim Bomi (Elle Fischer Editor)

9. Big Bang Top, 2PM Taecyeon, SS501 Kim Hyun Joong, SHINee Jonghyun - My dream group.
For Top, it will be the role of the Rapper and Leader for sure, Jonghyun will be Main Vocal, Kim Hyun Joong will be Sub-Vocal and Harmony, and Taecyeon will have the role of rapping and providing a bright smile?


Cho Minki (Loving Flower Boys Section Writer)

8. SHINee Key - Member whose activities in other arenas will be anticipated.
SHINee's previous healthy image shows a suitable amount of realism and also talents which are not detestable, this making people feel that he is more lively. Seems to be able to have good showings in variety in the future.


Kim Mongpo (Style List)

5. SHINee Jonghyun - Member who looks the most attractive/charismatic
Got this feeling while having a photoshoot with SHINee recently. Even though he has the looks of a teenager, but there is this air of manliness that I have never felt from him before. Like a playful soccer player.

7. SHINee Jonghyun - Member whose solo debut will be most anticipated.
His vocal and performance abilities have yet to integrate adequately into one body. If adding the strength of SM Fanclub, his solo will definitely have a success rate of at least 90%.


Roo Sujin (Mnet Writer)

2. SHINee Jonghyun & 2AM Changmin - Members who possesses the best vocal abilities.
SHINee's Jonghyun is an amazing idol who sings better during Live than in lipsynced performances. 2AM's Changmin is able to to reach out and touch me who is 30 years old with his voice.

Please take out with full credits
Translated by atlantis-x @soompi
Source: shakizi & 百度SHINee贴吧

Source: SHINee Soompi

Its only an extra commendation perk. The non-choices doesn't mean or define anything k, and they couldn't list like 101 persons for each categories, so don't get your panties offended and tied up in a knot. ..

Comments

[cinho.livejournal.com]

No onew? ;(

[qvinx.livejournal.com]

THIS THIS THIS

[2pm-hwaiting.livejournal.com]

lol Yes to everything about Jonghyun~~~~ <3
most attractive Minho? en no == JONGHYHUN!!! xD

[lightspeedsquid.livejournal.com]

Jonghyun who used to be a member of a punk rock band before entering SM

HOLD THE PHONE

WHAT IS THIS



WHAT

[filmsession.livejournal.com]

IKR WHAT I NEED SOME VIDS OR SOMETHING TO SHOW THIS AMAZINGNESS

[nimco.livejournal.com]

"Jonghyun who used to be a member of a punk rock band before entering SM"
how did I not know this? thats cool.

"Kim Hyun Joong will be Sub-Vocal and Harmony"
lol

[whetstone.livejournal.com]

Jonghyun who used to be a member of a punk rock band before entering SM

really? that's crazy

[jonghyun.livejournal.com]

he used to be the bassist ♥

[filmsession.livejournal.com]

elle has the jonghyun bias i love it ♥

[mangoquirks.livejournal.com]

This! :D
Elle has great taste, like (many of) us.

[silent-shout1.livejournal.com]

9. Big Bang Top, 2PM Taecyeon, SS501 Kim Hyun Joong, SHINee Jonghyun - My dream group.
Girl got good taste.

[iserial.livejournal.com]

As a person with major Onew bias, I am raged. >:(

[qvinx.livejournal.com]

THIS THIS THIS

[bystander.livejournal.com]

i am disheartened by the lack of onew.

[qvinx.livejournal.com]

THIS THIS THIS!

[cuidano.livejournal.com]

10. Big Bang & SHINee- ★The group that is most likely to last very long★

My 2 strongest group bias, I am happy =D. And my Jjong bias is satsified.

[izon-no-niwa.livejournal.com]

same here. love ELLE for putting in print our exact thoughts haha

[carmendove.livejournal.com]

I agree with some of these but they really need to list Onew along with Key for "Member whose activities in other arenas will be anticipated."
They are even funnier when together. Honestly, I see them both following in Eeteuk & Eunhyuk's footsteps in the future.



And I whole-heartedly disagree with Taemin for "Most stylish member"
Diva!Key all the way! The boy lives and breathes fashion.

[rockerista03.livejournal.com]

The lack of Onew disheartens me. Its really sad because his vocals are pretty good too. And whenever he goes on radio shows or variety shows, cameras and microphones tend to focus on him and/or the both of them.

is Onew biased, lol

[omgcats.livejournal.com]

YES CHANGMIN MENTION

HIS VOICE IS LIKE ORGASMS. REALLY GOOD ONES.

[cityscripts.livejournal.com]

MTE. I AM HAPPY ANYTHING 2AM RELATED IS ALSO MENTIONED.

[bubble-monkey9.livejournal.com]

is this only shinee cuts? I wanna read the rest of the list.

[xshinebrighterx.livejournal.com]

onew > jonghyun.

i would like to see the rest (aka whatever is not shinee)

[cityscripts.livejournal.com]

Okay, hi, Elle Girl, I love you for making this awesome list. My Jonghyun bias is happy. ♥

But no Onew? :(

Big Bang & SHINee- ★The group that is most likely to last very long★

I quite agree.

[shuwei.livejournal.com]

SHINee Key - Member whose activities in other arenas will be anticipated.
damn right. this guy could run a show.

ah the Jonghyun love :)

[hp-groupie.livejournal.com]

Obvious bias. XD I love the choices though, ESPECIALLY Key. But omg Onew! Where is he!? D:

AND NUMBER FOUR IS SO OBVIOUSLY GOING TO BE A MEMBER OF 2PM. I'LL GET OFF OMONA FOR A WHOLE TWO DAYS IF IT ISN'T!

NEEDS MOAR ONEW PLZ&TY

[stoptheraiin.livejournal.com]

Seriously....

Re: NEEDS MOAR ONEW PLZ&TY

[papyong.livejournal.com]

This x 500. *pouts*

[sya-fhya.livejournal.com]

is this only over boy groups?

[pyramidsonmars.livejournal.com]

your icon <3 Taemin is a big trap ugh.

[earenya-beryl.livejournal.com]

Love the mention of Jjong's taelnts and Changmin's voice, but seriously, a lot more people starting to only like Jjong's looks after he started to look more bad ass for the RDD promotions.

Dubu needs to be given a big break to show what he could do with that awesome voice of his, but perfection on stage wise, Jjong is better.

Taemininne, stylish? Yeah, stylishly cute. Umma knows all about fashion so he should be the most stylish.

Gorgeous Minho is Gorgeous!

Yey for Changmin's awesome vocals!!!!

[srsbsns.livejournal.com]

Sort of OT I was reading through the comments too fast and thought I saw the word "Jong-gasm" D:


His voice is awesome though :D

[stopthedisco.livejournal.com]

lol the ~noonas~ certainly love Shinee.

[pyramidsonmars.livejournal.com]

Big Bang Top, 2PM Taecyeon, SS501 Kim Hyun Joong, SHINee Jonghyun - My dream group.

I'd shit my pants

also, not enough about jailbait princess Taemin. And Onew plz.

[nautisch.livejournal.com]

not to be a jerk, but I'm sick of the jonghyun hate and "onew > jonghyun", "why no onew", etc whenever jonghyun so much as opens his mouth or other people talk about him. how dare they like jonghyun because onew is so clearly better!

they are both extremely talented people, and both of them have strengths and weaknesses. they compliment each other very well, and sing fabulous duets. jfc THEY ARE IN THE SAME BAND. I'm sure they don't view it as a contest, so why should we. and if we're being fair, jonghyun gets very little attention on variety shows- it's only when people talk about his voice that he really gets the limelight. onew/minho/taemin are the variety show darlings.

feel free to hate me and my essay, I'm just sick of the unnecessary bitching from all sides.

[miximel.livejournal.com]

all of this, yes.