160726 JTBC Girl Spirit E02: Performances

[kevinmchale.livejournal.com]

PERFORMANCES

GIRLS’ GENERATION — 힘 내! Way To Go 🎧

BOA — 아틀란티스 소녀 Atlantis Princess 🎧

MAYA — 나를 외치다 Shout Myself 🎧

IVY — 바본가 봐 I Must Be A Fool 🎧

CARNIVAL — 거위의 꿈 Goose’s Dream 🎧

S.E.S — Just A Feeling 🎧

JTBC Entertainment

Comments

(frozen)

[kevinmchale.livejournal.com]

Team A went up against each other performing their 'fight song' and 100 audience members, 5 mentors and the other 6 other contestants cast their votes.

#1 MINJAE (SONAMOO) 90
#2 KEI (LOVELYZ) 88
#3 SEUNGHEE (OH MY GIRL) 87
#4 DAWON (COSMIC GIRLS) 83
#5 SUNGYEON (PLEDIS GIRLZ) 81
#6 SEUNGHEE (CLC) 65

Minjae and Kei got to release their song digitally for being top 2.

[msgrottesca.livejournal.com]

the obvious pitch correction on these performances is lowkey ruining the show for me =/

[mangomuffins.livejournal.com]

yeah it's really obvious that they've edited the audio and it's so fucking stupid to do that on a singing competition show lmao

[msgrottesca.livejournal.com]

On a show like Produce 101 it bothered me SLIGHTLY less since it was an all-around idol show rather than strictly vocals, but for this... it's really stupid and misguided to be serving me autotune vocals on a singing competition LOL.

[pseudo-shigure.livejournal.com]

oh really? lol it sounds live i thought and i like it better than the usual music shows bc their voices are clearer

[msgrottesca.livejournal.com]

The singing is live, they're just editing their voices in post-production before airing the show. Or have pitch correction on the mics, that's a thing too.

[mangomuffins.livejournal.com]

i do think there are elements of live singing but the vocals sound so heavily processed, like they're singing in a studio. it's not completely live

[kevinmchale.livejournal.com]

seunghee 😭😭😭

mess i just realized it should be whose in that poster 💀

[ginger-star.livejournal.com]

But where oh god is my studio vers of Seunghee's Dream Girl x Windy Day mashup? My YouTube audio rip just won't do!

But jesus CLC Seunghee deserves more love. She did a great job here... Everyone in Korea has just collectively decided screw CLC I guess :( Like wow...I can't even believe she's on the bottom after watching her performance.

[bri-and-red.livejournal.com]

I'm confused, weren't there way more singers in the first episode? Do people get eliminated?

ETA: Oops, so this is just team A and I'm guessing everyone else is on team B?

[bmo.livejournal.com]

sungyeon should've gotten 1st and i know THEY ALL KNOW IT. the sonamoo girl did rly bad imo and kei should've been 3rd.

ppl r so easily impressed it's ridiculous? the audience was biased af and way too nice.

[msgrottesca.livejournal.com]

The Sonamoo girl has some of the best technique out of this entire group (and I say this w/ zero bias cuz idek her lmao) I don't like ballads like this much but I don't think she did objectively bad at all, everything was very high quality in terms of vocal technique, pitch, control, placement, etc. But I have no idea how Kei placed so high or how Sungyeon placed so low! If it were up to me they would be switched - Kei's performance was not only almost exactly the same as her first one, but also super pitchy apparently since it has the most pitch correction on it of any of these. She sounds straight up autotuned on entire sections of the song.

[bmo.livejournal.com]

About the Sonamoo girl, pitch wise she was fine but everything else was a bit messy to me. We can just disagree lol! I didn't like it too much and the people I was watching with felt the same too. I think she did second best after Sungyeon overall though! Everyone else was either forgettable or just not as good as those two.

[sks2k5.livejournal.com]

Why do they ALWAYS use the original version of "Just a Feeling" when it was the Remix Version that was promoted? Sigh.

(I got into K-pop right when S.E.S released that album.)

[pseudo-shigure.livejournal.com]

i love how u can actually hear their real voices. now why can't music shows audio is like this?

[maknaeroli.livejournal.com]

Atlantis Princess brings me back so much I adore BoA and I loved Kei's voice with it I'm in love



this princess <3

still working through the perfs but oh my girl's seunghee usually rocks it~!!