i'm not done watching yet but wtf at the judging for jihyo... those 2 pursed lip bitter judges taking out their own issues w body image on her and jyp trying to act like he's being 'reasonable' and not fighting for her..
jihyo is well spoken, seems way more natural in front of the camera and clearly has benefited from her yrs of training all of which was neglected because she's not v v thin?
I'm worried that this will affect her stability / self esteem, esp since she's so young.
also if this is going to be the format for the entire show, it's going to get boring fast. they're just constantly walking to a different side of the stage
I still didn't watch this episode and after reading your comment I'm not sure if I should watch this. Jihyo is one of my faves and I don't know if I could deal with them talking about her weight. She is not even fat.
I can not with that photographer going in for Jihyo's weight. She's young, wtf. This is the kind of shit that gives female idols all these depressing thoughts... like she's already stressed enough about the competition don't add this on to make her self-esteem completely implode. :/
Tsuyu reaaaaally surprised me. Based on her first performance I wasn't expecting any vocals from her, at least not the kind she showcased. I see a lot of potential with her voice too, it's a bit raw. I honestly enjoyed her performance a lot more than Nayeon's. Nayeon is a tricky one, she was my first choice going on but has fallen a lot. :/ And I can't even say it's an editing thing because the comments she sometimes makes with or without editing still sound... anyway, she always tries to do too much and that hurts her. She got lucky here. I know it's a show but I also don't like how she went for the weakest to secure her spot.
Dahyun/Sana/Chaeryoung: That was such a tough one. Chaeryoung was soooo good, I was surprised. I actually agreed with that one. I thought they were all good tbh but Chaeryoung's was definitely the dance I'd go back to rewatch.
Jiwon/Jeungyeon: Honestly, had it not been for her lack of confidence and nervousness I would have chosen Jiwon as a winner here, because I didn't really like Jeungyeon's. They can both do so much better so these were bad performances for me.
Somi/Minyoung: I loved Somi, and I know Minyoung had some pitch problems but so did Somi and hers were more obvious to me, so if she ends up winning this over Minyoung, it'd be... kind of odd?
And I have to say I don't like how it seems they will be dragging the Natty vs Momo thing for the whole show. This a child vs a woman, idk it's weird to me. They have different styles imo. It's like how the show will likely draw out Dahyun fallen each week and then redeem herself. Seems beyond scripted.
And omg I had tears when Chaeyeon left :/ I feel bad for Chaeryeong. If anything based on the presscon from before the show I had expected Eunsuh to be the one eliminated first. I kind of agree with others in hoping the Chae sis get to be in the same group, but I've come to really love Chaeryeong.
I see a lot of people rooting for momo. Personally for me she's really flat. Yeah, she killed in dancing, but back dancer dances good too. She has no star quality.
I'm kind of iffy about somi at the start, but she's grown on me. Now she's the stand out for me. Her performance a bit unstable, but somehow I still prefer it over minyoung.
buoajbvkb the Jihyo thing is making me want to hit something. Her photo was one of the best! It makes me even more mad the comments came for the two women. In general the photographer seems kind of an asshole.
thank god they are uploading the subs in dailymotion, I'll watch later but I've read spoilers and well... :/
And whoever thinks Jihyo's fat should seriously get their eye sight checked, she's gorgeous and has twice the confidence most of these girls have (no pun intended)
Commenting as I watch the battles: I can practically hear Nayeon thinking. She has zero naturalness. lol Gain said the same. I agree with JYP, Nayeon is better but Tzuyu has more charms. Jiwon looks really uncomfortable in the stage. Jungyeon was a little bit stiff in the beginning. I love Dahyun style. She just dances like she has fun and is contagious. Chaeryoung is one of the most natural ones. Sana reminds me to myself dancing so now I have a soft spot for her. I cannot choose between these three. lol the judges are me Somi was not bad but it wasn't special. Minyoung usually looks scared so this stage was a pleasant surprise. Don't cry baby, is just a little mistake.
I really loved Chaeyong and Jihyo’s photos. I was really pissed that Jihyo got moved to Minor because the photographers said she was “chubby”. Her photo was stronger than Tzuyu’s imo.
I was really surprised by Chaeyeon being the first elimination. I thought that Eunsuh would be the first one gone because she doesn’t really stand out to me.
I hope that Jiwon is back in Major soon. She's the strongest singer but she needs to get her confidence back. I knew that Chaeryeong/Dahyun/Sana would end in three way tie). Chaeryeong deserved her win, but I was sad when Dahyun and Sana went to Minor because almost all of my faves are in Minor. I was rooting for Somi but she looked really nervous so she kind of suffered. Minyoung was confident but she hit a bad note towards the end so that hurt her. I’m really nervous about the result.
My Ideal Line Up For Twice After This Episode 3: Jihyo, Dahyun, Sana, Somi, Chaeryeong, Momo and Minyoung.
Honestly, I can't see anything special in Natty and at the same time don't understand why they drag Momo all the time. I mean, you're trying to create stars that would be popular among people. I am people and I don't get your point, okay?
i got sooooooo mad at them calling jihyo fat :( jihyo is perfect, she's not far at all! it was worse because the photographer told her she was fat, causing her to hide, then criticised her for hiding when it was the photographer's view of her image causing her to have insecurities and not want to be filmed. jihyo honestly couldn't win, and then the photographers ganged up on her. she's not chubby at all, she's healthy, and she's young. she already said she was going to start dieting afterwards. this is the kind of thing that gives girls complexes and eating disorders. :( (i'm happy to see in the preview jihyo doing all about that bass though....own it bb)
i think i agreed with all of the results so far...i love sana but chaeryeong owned that stage. and minyoung definitely did better than somi.
i still think my ideal list would be somi, jihyo, chaeyoung, minyoung/jungyeon, dahyun, mina and sana. i love mina too much to swap her for anyone else, and sana is still one of my biases along with somi and jihyo.
jiwon seems so so nervous that even though she's super talented, she doesn't really have any star power....poor thing :(
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 06:00 am (UTC)jihyo is well spoken, seems way more natural in front of the camera and clearly has benefited from her yrs of training all of which was neglected because she's not v v thin?
I'm worried that this will affect her stability / self esteem, esp since she's so young.
also if this is going to be the format for the entire show, it's going to get boring fast. they're just constantly walking to a different side of the stage
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 02:00 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 06:20 am (UTC)Tsuyu reaaaaally surprised me. Based on her first performance I wasn't expecting any vocals from her, at least not the kind she showcased. I see a lot of potential with her voice too, it's a bit raw. I honestly enjoyed her performance a lot more than Nayeon's. Nayeon is a tricky one, she was my first choice going on but has fallen a lot. :/ And I can't even say it's an editing thing because the comments she sometimes makes with or without editing still sound... anyway, she always tries to do too much and that hurts her. She got lucky here. I know it's a show but I also don't like how she went for the weakest to secure her spot.
Dahyun/Sana/Chaeryoung: That was such a tough one. Chaeryoung was soooo good, I was surprised. I actually agreed with that one. I thought they were all good tbh but Chaeryoung's was definitely the dance I'd go back to rewatch.
Jiwon/Jeungyeon: Honestly, had it not been for her lack of confidence and nervousness I would have chosen Jiwon as a winner here, because I didn't really like Jeungyeon's. They can both do so much better so these were bad performances for me.
Somi/Minyoung: I loved Somi, and I know Minyoung had some pitch problems but so did Somi and hers were more obvious to me, so if she ends up winning this over Minyoung, it'd be... kind of odd?
And I have to say I don't like how it seems they will be dragging the Natty vs Momo thing for the whole show. This a child vs a woman, idk it's weird to me. They have different styles imo. It's like how the show will likely draw out Dahyun fallen each week and then redeem herself. Seems beyond scripted.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 05:59 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 06:25 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 07:57 am (UTC)There is no sub when watching it.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 02:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 06:17 pm (UTC)Thanks. :)
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 01:51 pm (UTC)I see a lot of people rooting for momo. Personally for me she's really flat. Yeah, she killed in dancing, but back dancer dances good too. She has no star quality.
I'm kind of iffy about somi at the start, but she's grown on me. Now she's the stand out for me. Her performance a bit unstable, but somehow I still prefer it over minyoung.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 02:33 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 02:44 pm (UTC)And whoever thinks Jihyo's fat should seriously get their eye sight checked, she's gorgeous and has twice the confidence most of these girls have (no pun intended)
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 03:35 pm (UTC)I can practically hear Nayeon thinking. She has zero naturalness. lol Gain said the same.
I agree with JYP, Nayeon is better but Tzuyu has more charms.
Jiwon looks really uncomfortable in the stage. Jungyeon was a little bit stiff in the beginning.
I love Dahyun style. She just dances like she has fun and is contagious. Chaeryoung is one of the most natural ones. Sana reminds me to myself dancing so now I have a soft spot for her. I cannot choose between these three. lol the judges are me
Somi was not bad but it wasn't special. Minyoung usually looks scared so this stage was a pleasant surprise. Don't cry baby, is just a little mistake.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-23 05:32 pm (UTC)I was really surprised by Chaeyeon being the first elimination. I thought that Eunsuh would be the first one gone because she doesn’t really stand out to me.
I hope that Jiwon is back in Major soon. She's the strongest singer but she needs to get her confidence back. I knew that Chaeryeong/Dahyun/Sana would end in three way tie). Chaeryeong deserved her win, but I was sad when Dahyun and Sana went to Minor because almost all of my faves are in Minor. I was rooting for Somi but she looked really nervous so she kind of suffered. Minyoung was confident but she hit a bad note towards the end so that hurt her. I’m really nervous about the result.
My Ideal Line Up For Twice After This Episode 3: Jihyo, Dahyun, Sana, Somi, Chaeryeong, Momo and Minyoung.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-24 08:22 am (UTC)Also, wtf??? Jihyo doesn't look fat!
no subject
Date: 2015-05-26 04:13 am (UTC)My final: Jihyo, Jungyeon, Rapper girl, Momo, Somi and maybe Minyoung.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-27 01:30 am (UTC)i think i agreed with all of the results so far...i love sana but chaeryeong owned that stage. and minyoung definitely did better than somi.
i still think my ideal list would be somi, jihyo, chaeyoung, minyoung/jungyeon, dahyun, mina and sana. i love mina too much to swap her for anyone else, and sana is still one of my biases along with somi and jihyo.
jiwon seems so so nervous that even though she's super talented, she doesn't really have any star power....poor thing :(