Yoo Nina at fault for using SHINee’s Jonghyun?

[sequinstilettos.livejournal.com]

Prior to what was reported earlier, more information regarding Yoo Nina’s incident with SHINee’s Jonghyun and fans have been revealed.

Yoo Nina is currently at fault for intentionally spreading false rumors in order to ride on Jonghyun’s fame. Although that still doesn’t justify what the fans did, she was the one who brought this incident upon herself.

Yoo Nina’s agency continues to state that it wasn’t her fault, and still believes that the fans have been causing chaos by spreading those rumors, and will continue to take legal action.

Some fans left a couple comments on a bulletin board stating their feelings, “Yoo Nina is trying to use SHINee’s Jonghyun, and now she’s making SHINee and their fans look terribly bad,” and “This all needs to stop. SHINee’s reputation is getting ruined.”

Proof that Yoo Nina indeed started the rumors herself have also been surfacing on two Naver blogs, viewable here and here. It shows her posts and how she intentionally used SHINee’s name for her own doing, which resulted in this chaos.
 

Jonghyun also mentioned about this incident on Shim Shim Ta Pa at 1:18

 

EDIT*

What the whole fuss was all about:

Basically (what the Allkpop article epically fails to tell you in detail @_@) is Nina started getting into the controversy when she put up a picture of her and a “friend” at a restaurant – she was covering her face, and the guy’s face was mosaiced so you couldn’t see his features, but his side profile (and what was left of the mosaic) looked a lot like Jonghyun.

No problem ,right? Wrong. She spans a whole year (or more) writing diary entries and comments on her friends’ CyWorld pages on how she and “Jjong” “Jonghyunnie” are dating, and one of the comments to her friend, she even says she and “Jjong” and her friend should go on a double date with one of the members from “Jjong”’s band.

Other times, she wrote happy birthdays on her diary entries on the date of other SHINee members’ birthdays, and this goes on and on and on, basically making it look like she’s dating Jonghyun. And don’t think this is all for fun, because on CyWorld, there’s a checkbox when you leave comments on your friends’ pages to mark your comment “hidden” so that only that person can see it.

None of her comments regarding her relationship with this “Jjong” were ever hidden comments – basically saying, she wants people to see them. If she was really dating a superstar, wouldn’t she be super careful about making sure no one sees those comments?

Then, she signed up on SHINee World (SHINee official fan cafe) under a nickname “Mannerful Shawol”, but unfortunately for her, her IP address got tracked, and all the comments she left on SHINee World (saying things like “Leave them alone” “I talked with Nina and she’s a nice girl!” and “You guys are just hurting Jjong oppa” etc.) were… Ta dah… The same IP address as her CyWorld…

This got so out of control that SHINee members started being monitored on every single phone call by their management (because SM started fearing that Jonghyun might really be dating her), and they were cut off from meeting anyone outside of their work for a while (so yeah, here’s where the damage part comes in, for all of you guys saying “No big deal” @_@).

Jonghyun’s close friend, at the request of SHINee World members, wrote a letter talking about how it’s difficult to see Jonghyun and SHINee members losing privileges because of the rumors started by this girl, and confirmed that Jonghyun does not even know what this girl looks like.

Then, Nina doesn’t stop there. She writes on her friend’s page (once again without the “hide comment” function) “Jjong said sorry to me about making his friend write that letter” when in fact, SHINee World members were the ones who had asked Jonghyun’s friend for that letter.

cr: SHINee soompi thread

source: allkpoop, sequinstilettos

Comments

[cookiedealer.livejournal.com]

As great as her boobs are, they don't distract me nearly enough from her face. Ugh...

[831panda831.livejournal.com]

THIS

[kittycurious.livejournal.com]

Not sure who she is, or what this controversy is, but...
now she’s making SHINee and their fans look terribly bad

Nah, the fans do that on their own. They don't need any help.

[rinni1905.livejournal.com]

I've hear this accused ever since the controversy start....

Well, your comment makes the sentence"now this girl and her whole scandal make SHINee and Shawol look like devil" clearer.

[yaknowhattamean.livejournal.com]

Actions like her's have consequences. She probably doesn't deserve to be terrorized by fangirls (does anyone?), but she does need to take responsibility and face the consequences.

[chewyish.livejournal.com]

this sfm.
you don't cause a mess and expect things to go smoothly afterwards right? cyberbullying is bad and all but girl needs to step up :|

[sujulover4510.livejournal.com]

LOL allkpoop xD

[citzera.livejournal.com]

Gdi.

Girl, get checked or something. This is ridiculous.

However that doesn't give Shawols the right to terrorize her for it. Would've been better to sue her than to start an online war. Stay classy.

[rinni1905.livejournal.com]

However that doesn't give Shawols the right to terrorize her for it. Would've been better to sue her than to start an online war. Stay classy?

It's hard to do though, and the company doesn't have the proof of what Shawol's doing. And you know, in Asia, sueing takes a lot of money. And do you find logical in sueing someone in the Internet for spreading false rumor of your idol? If the idol didn't take action because they wanted to be civil, then fan wouldn't do anything out of it. Online war is a must.

[chickenpl0x.livejournal.com]

Not saying I agree with the Shawols attacking her, but I do not pity her at all.. you want fame, you got it...

[shan-ah-non.livejournal.com]

bitch, get a life

[bumie.livejournal.com]

lol oh , i didn't know this way to get famous still exist.

[boogie14.livejournal.com]

totally OT but in the video from SSTP
they mention a rumor about "onew's little sister"
and even Onew said that this little girl did resemble him a lot
so, i'm curious to see it
does anyone has it?

[fay-of-sunshine.livejournal.com]

ooh~

this sounds so much more interesting. I was too second-hand embarrassed to watch SSTP vid. -_-

[violetrosie.livejournal.com]

[violetrosie.livejournal.com]

Also relevant:

[killclosedrown.livejournal.com]

So there's proof that she made all this shit up, but no proof that Shawols actually did attack her like she said they did. If it's true then obviously the shawols went too far and should have just ignored her, but really I have no reason to believe this chick when everything I know about her is that she's been lying for the past year or so saying she was dating Jonghyun to just increase her fame.

Regardless, if she wasn't attacked online before, she probably will be now =/

[chewyish.livejournal.com]

dnw korean miley cyrus lookalike.
and wow, this girl is like jessi-slaughter troll status. wtf was she thinking.
well she can say goodbye to ever having a career after this :|
and if she does then, smh @ you korea. because idols have to train and work they're butts off to get recognized. shortcuts don't work girl, especially ones like these.

[belovedseason.livejournal.com]

Noona didn't mean it, I'm sure.

[mayam-mj90.livejournal.com]

So embarassing to have your face and boobs pasted all over the internet with captions "CRAZY BITCH".

But yeah, she's got mental issues especially how she tries to defend herself yet leaving behind such unmistakable evidences.

[sungiebot.livejournal.com]

embarrassing. had it coming, how dumb can you get? damn.

[mileyichigo.livejournal.com]

i want to see the evidence of what the shawols did to making her life a living hell

what did they say ?

[rinni1905.livejournal.com]

Yeah, I don't think that Shawol should do this to her, but you know that Shawols are really civil, and they probably the most peaceful fanclub among SM boybands' fanclubs. But saying that this girl shouldn't be terrorize is a very naive thinking.

If Shawol didn't have any reaction from this girl wrong doing, what would this girl do? I doubt that you want SHINee to live an unsocial life. They're still young, just because they're an idol, they have to endure many things that you don't even imagine. What Shawol did is to protect SHINee and their reputation. False rumor can result more anti, and every fan doesn't want that happen to their idol.

This girl is seriously at fault, she needs someone to help her. If her doing did nothing wrong, why did Jjong have to put this in SSTP? He might have felt very depressed and upset. You know how carefree Jjong is, he loves to hang out with friends, shopping and so on. But this girl made it hard, if the rumors were stronger, probably another case of Jaebum will appear. I agree that Shawol shouldn't do anything to harm her. But wasn't that Nina the one wanted this?

I feel frustrated with some of the comment about how rude and terrible Shawol is because of this girl. Honestly, some of you didn't even know the situation, and dumped all of this in Shawol's heads. Everytime someone did wrong, it's fan and idol are at fault. What logical is that?

[mileyichigo.livejournal.com]

totally agree, ill be glad when this is over

[annanuna.livejournal.com]

wow stupid bitch with nice boobs..
I think she's living in stone age, for being stupid using same IP address

[melonfucka.livejournal.com]

[earenya-beryl.livejournal.com]

"Just be happy it wasn't Onew.. Or else she would have been dead by now :)"

Why do I have the feeling this is so true...T-T

[cinnabun11.livejournal.com]

that's some real bullshit
SHINee shouldn't have to suffer because of this wannabe

[olive-101.livejournal.com]

too bad cause she's quite pretty. =/

[kimishim.livejournal.com]

she looks plastic fantastic. nice boobs etc.
but lol wrong move. this will be the beginning and the end of her fame unless she wants to pull this stunt again with another shinee member.

[cher-ex3.livejournal.com]

Welcome to showbiz.

[cookiehangul24.livejournal.com]

She need to get some help asap O_O